Skip to main content

Fiber Network In Sugar; Easter Egg Hunt; Sugar Days 2024; New Asst. City Clerk; New P&Z Comissioner From Salem

 


Fiber Network in Sugar City

This week in city council meeting, we reviewed the latest information and options available for getting fiber high speed internet in the older areas of Sugar City. (I spoke about this in an earlier post.)

Over the past couple of years, the council and city staff researched various options, and we eventually put out a call for specific proposals. This week we voted 3 to 1 to join with the county's agreement with Fybercom to provide the option for fiber-based broadband to the city's residents. I voted to support piggybacking on the County/Fybercom agreement.

During the past several months, I read numerous academic studies and pro/con trade journal and non-profit "political lobbyist style" articles regarding the advantages and disadvantages of city-owned fiber networks. I read 4+ years of council minutes from other cities that have had to make the decision to own or not the fiber network in their city. I and other city officials met with an official from Providence, Utah to talk about their city-owned fiber network. I listened to information from the fiber network director for the city of Ammon. I contacted a city official in Provo to get their take on Provo's (mis)adventures with their fiber network. I listened to the county's officials regarding their project agreement with Fybercom. And, of course, I reviewed the information we gathered from the proposals the city received from companies interested in working with the city on this.

In the end, I decided against the city owning the fiber network in Sugar. Some residents have asked me about my reasoning. Let me try to summarize:

  • Funding. We'd have to pay for the fiber network upfront. I don't have an appetite for bonding of any kind for this. And I'm not a fan of Local Improvement Districts (LIDs) that can be used to require residents to pay for infrastructure repairs and upgrades and such. We could apply for various state or federal grants, but that is hit and miss, never certain we'd get the grants and the amounts necessary.
  • Population Density. I know Sugar is growing, but it would still be questionable whether we could get enough income from the network to pay for itself and its administration, certainly in the first number of years of the project.
  • Timeline. If we did this project on our own, it would drag out over several, maybe even many, years. 
  • Savings. The monthly savings promised to residents by having a city-owned fiber network commonly don't end up being as great as initially projected. And if you factor in the initial cost to residents through bonding or LIDs or connection fees, which can run into the thousands per household, it could be 10+ years before the household starts to realize the promised savings. And that is if everything else stays the same as far as no increases in monthly rates or costs for upgrades, etc.
  • Administration. A city-owned network requires a new city administrator and department. I'm not in favor of this for fiber.
  • Fiber as Utility. I'm not convinced that fiber should be viewed as a utility like water and sewer services for the city to own and manage. Residents don't have to have fiber internet services from the city as there are other private options available. I'm not sure we need the city competing against them.
  • Research & Development. If all the fiber networks in the country were government owned, I suspect the research and development in the fiber industry would dry up (unless we all want to spend more tax money on such things).
  • Access. I don't consider myself a conspiracy theorist at all. However, I don't think it would be a good idea for everyone's internet access to be owned by the government.
  • Other Options. There are other options out there, and being developed, that could lead to high speed connectivity without using fiber, satellite-based service, for example. If such options become feasible and practical, I'd prefer not to have the city owning a fiber network that residents choose not to use.

The agreement the city will enter in with the County & Fybercom is still being worked out. The main goals will be to allow residents the option to hook up their house for free and for several reasonable options to be available for monthly high speed service. Residents can choose to keep their current service or change.


Easter Egg Hunt

The Annual Ester Egg Hunt is on Saturday March 30th at 10am at the old junior high gym. The Easter Bunny will be on hand for photos.

Sugar Days 2024

Sugar Days is only three months away, Saturday, June 15. We'll also have a concert in the park again this year on Friday evening. So plan on enjoying the music of Cedar Junction Friday night and then again Saturday afternoon!

Vendors and organizations put the date on your calendar, and we'll have booths spaces available for reservations soon.

New Assistant City Clerk & New P&Z Member

This week the mayor swore in Vickie Robertson as a new Assistant City Clerk/Treasurer. And for the first time we now have a resident of Salem as a voting member of the Planning and Zoning Commission: Rick Robertson, who was sworn in by Mayor Adams as well.

Popular posts from this blog

Sugar Days 2025; P&Z Vacancy; Little Park Update; Little Libraries; FT City Employee Opening; CERT

  Sugar Days 2025 Sugar Days is one week away! We hope everyone in our community can come out and enjoy the family-friendly day in Heritage park. I'd like to highlight a few things: The Historical Society will be hosting a silent auction as a fund raiser for their continuing goal to fund a new museum. Please stop by their booth. Grand Teton Farm and Mill (ancientgrains.com) is sponsoring a 5-minute Teton Dam Flood Memories Project. A group of BYU-Idaho students will be hosting brief interviews with people who have memories to share about the flood. The booth will be set up next to the Historical Society's space, so please come by and get your memories recorded for posterity. At 10am at the city's tent, we'll be presenting awards for the Citizen of the Year (Kevin Miyasaki) and Public Servant of the Year Award (Lynsey Bean). Please come and congratulate Kevin and Lynsey for this well-deserved recognition! Planning & Zoning Commission Vacancy We're looking for a n...
Read more

USS Idaho; Sugar Days; City Budget 2025-26; Population Change in ID; Happy Independence Day!

  I recently heard a presentation on the upcoming commissioning of the newest nuclear submarine in the US Navy, the USS Idaho. As the Commissioning Committee's website says: The future USS IDAHO SSN 799 is a leading-edge Virginia Class nuclear-powered fast attack submarine being built by General Dynamics Electric Boat in Connecticut. She was christened in March 2024, and is likely to be commissioned into the Navy fleet during the spring of 2026. It was fascinating to hear about all of the attention to detail that goes into making this sub truly representative of our great state. The Committee is accepting artistic, original, iconic Idaho works to be included in the interior of the sub, such as photographs and paintings. If you or someone you know would like to have work considered, please go to their website for more information . It would be quite an honor to have your work accepted.  The expected life of the sub is 35 years. Sugar Days 2025 Thanks for another great Sugar Day...
Read more

Teton Dam: 5-Minute Histories; Sugar Days; City Parks Long-Term Planning

Teton Dam: 5-Minute Histories Project It's been 49 years since the devastating flood did its best to wipe Sugar City off the map. In the summer of 2026, there will be a big commemoration in Rexburg, Sugar City, and the surrounding areas. The multi-day commemoration will include lectures and museum events, bus and walking tours in Rexburg and Sugar City, and shuttles out to the newly improved facilities at the dam site, etc. (This photo, taken after the flood waters had receded, is looking east on 3rd North in Sugar. The old sugar factory and the WWII POW camp building can be seen in the left corner.) This year, as part of our Sugar Days 2025 celebration, we're going to have a booth set up for residents who remember the flood to drop in and record up to a five-minute video in which they share their memories of that fateful time. We invite all who would like to participate. Sugar Days 2025 Speaking of Sugar Days, we invite all residents, sponsors, and vendors to put Saturday June...
Read more